Rules of Appellate Procedure – Comment Period Closes January 4, 2027

URAP008. Stay or injunction pending appeal. Amend. The Committee proposes amending Rule 8 to: 1) add procedures for a response or reply to be filed; and 2) add page limitations for any motion, response, or reply.

URAP023. Motions. Amend. The Committee proposes amending Rule 23 to add a page limitation.

URAP023B. Motion to remand for findings necessary to determination of ineffective assistance of counsel claim. Amend. The Committee proposes amending Rule 23B to: 1) add a page limitation for any motion, response, or reply; and 2) add a procedure for filing an overlength motion for a 23B motion.

 

Utah Courts

View more posts from this author
One thought on “Rules of Appellate Procedure – Comment Period Closes January 4, 2027”
  1. David Ferguson

    I strongly disagree with the proposal to add a word limit to Rule 23B remand motions and urge the Court not to adopt it.

    A 23B remand is a bizarre creature, one that exists in only a few states. In most other states, a defendant who raises an ineffective-assistance claim supported by extra-record evidence must go through the state’s post-conviction process. That defendant files not a motion or brief but a petition, which works like a complaint. Without rule 23B, Utah defendants would follow the same process. Complaints and petitions have no word limit. A plaintiff is entitled to make an initial pleading as robust as necessary to state a claim for relief.

    A 23B remand motion is already odd because it does the work of a petition, with the added burden that the entire argument supporting the claims must be fully developed and submitted in the same filing. It operates as a hybrid of a reverse 12(b)(6) motion and a summary judgment motion. The only relief available to the movant is an evidentiary hearing, and the movant can get it only by attaching sworn statements of fact. It is a chimera of different procedures, and relief is harder to obtain than under any of the procedures it resembles.

    A word limit would add an undue restriction on top of that. Word limits do apply to 12(b)(6) and summary judgment motions (9,000 words, compared with the 14,000 proposed here). But a 23B motion also takes the place of a post-conviction petition, which is a complaint and carries no word limit, for good policy reasons. A party should be allowed to plead as many facts and raise as many claims for relief as needed to succeed on the merits. A 23B motion can require a substantial number of facts. The movant must identify everything relevant in what are often multi-day trials, along with whatever extra-record facts are necessary to establish the need for remand.

    A possible middle ground is to impose the 14,000-word limit but exclude the statement of facts and the claims for relief from the count. That would give the remand motion the flexibility of a petition while keeping attorneys focused in their argument. A motion to file an overlength brief should, of course, remain available when appropriate.

    Finally, although this point falls outside the scope of the specific proposal, the Court should consider revisiting the 23B remand process entirely. Its chimera nature has significant disadvantages. Summary judgment offers a useful comparison. It was designed to save time and expense in litigation but over time became another way to bog down and protract it, increasing costs and decreasing efficiency. The 23B remand process works similarly. An attorney may believe an issue will win on the record alone but feel compelled to delay the appeal to investigate a potential 23B motion. Declining to pursue the motion will all but bar relief on the issue in post-conviction, because the procedural bars prohibit a defendant from raising a claim that appellate counsel could have raised. See McCloud v. State, 2021 UT 51.

    That pressure pushes appellate attorneys either to investigate and file 23B motions or to advise clients to gamble on waiving the associated claims in favor of others counsel thinks will win. I suspect most appellate attorneys rightly feel obligated to pursue the motions rather than gamble with their clients’ post-conviction opportunities. That in turn requires the appellate courts to spend their limited resources on these motions. Most states handle this type of litigation primarily in the district court through standard post-conviction proceedings, because the district court is better suited to most of what the process requires.

    An ideal process would keep a limited 23B rule for extra-record issues that can be addressed efficiently on direct appeal. Better yet, the Court could lift the post-conviction bar for claims that could have been raised in a 23B motion but were not, based on counsel’s judgment. Giving appellate attorneys the flexibility to include a 23B motion or to pass the claim on to post-conviction, expecting that another issue will resolve the appeal more efficiently, would better capture the efficiencies the 23B remand was designed to achieve and free up precious resources for the appellate courts.

     
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *