Utah Courts
UCJA Rule 14-205 (Code of Judicial Administration)
UCJA Rule 14-205 (Code of Judicial Administration)
Rule 14-205. Board.
(a) Number and terms. The Board must consist of no fewer than 13 but no more than 15 voting members, including 11 elected lawyers and two non-lawyers appointed by the Supreme Court. Except as otherwise provided, the term of office of each commissioner is three years and until a successor is elected and qualified.
(b) Vacancies. A lawyer vacancy on the Board occurs by reason of death, resignation, incapacity, retirement, removal, change of residence from Utah, or upon the incumbent ceasing to be an active lawyer licensee in good standing. A vacancy created by a lawyer commissioner must be filled by the remaining Board members by either:
(b)(1) conducting a special election;
(b)(2) appointing a successor from among the active lawyer licensees whose business mailing addresses on the records of the Bar are in the division from which the commissioner was elected, who must serve until the following annual election; or
(b)(3) filling the vacancy through the next regular annual election.
The Board may establish the term of the successor to be either a one, two or full three-year term, provided that there would be not more than three but not fewer than two commissioners from the Third Division whose terms expire in any one year and not more than five but not fewer than four commissioners on the Board whose terms expire in any one year.
(b)(4) A President’s unexpired Commission term must be filled in the regular election cycle immediately preceding the time he or she succeeds to the office of President.
(c) Removal. A lawyer commissioner may be removed from the Board by:
(c)(1) The vote of eight of the twelve commissioners (other than the commissioner proposed for removal) at a meeting of which advance notice of the removal vote is given as provided in paragraph 14-204(a)(2), provided that commissioners who are eligible to vote but who are not in attendance at the meeting may submit their vote in writing to the executive director; or
(c)(2) The vote of a majority of the active lawyer licensees in the division which elected the commissioner voting in a special election held for the purpose of consideration of removal. Ballots must be emailed to the lawyer licensees’ address of record with the Bar20 days after the filing of a petition calling for removal signed by 10% of the active lawyer licensees in the division which elected the commissioner. Ballots are due by 9:59 p.m. Mountain Time 15 days after emailing and the results must be tabulated and announced not more than 45 days after the filing of the petition.
(d) General powers. The Board may exercise all powers necessary and proper to carry out the duties and responsibilities of the Bar and the purposes of Article 1, Integration and Management, and may exercise all authority which is not specifically reserved to the Supreme Court.
(e) Election notice. Notice of election of commissioners and of the divisions from which they must be elected during the current year must be emailed to the active lawyer licensees of the Bar in that division no later than 90 days prior to the date the election closes.
(f) Nomination. Commissioners are nominated by written petition complying with Article 1, Integration and Management, and filed with the executive director at least 60 days prior to the date the election closes. The petitions must be signed by ten active lawyer licensees whose business mailing addresses on the records of the Bar are in the division from which the election is to be held. Only active lawyer licensees eligible to vote in that division may be nominated to serve as commissioner.
(g) Form of petition. The executive director must prepare a form of petition for the nomination of commissioners and furnish copies to any active lawyer licensee upon request. Nominations may be made on the forms, but nominations in any other form of petition which complies with Article 1, Integration and Management and these Bylaws must be sufficient.
(h) Election procedures.
(h)(1) Ballots must be provided to all active lawyer licensees in each division in which an election is to be held, containing the alphabetized names of those lawyer licensees who have been nominated from the respective divisions. The ballots must be provided electronically to active lawyer licensees at their email address of record with the Bar at least 15 days prior to the date the election closes.
(h)(2) Ballots must be submitted no later than 9:59 p.m. Mountain Time on the day the election closes.
(h)(3) Successful candidates will be notified by the Executive Director. The President must call a meeting of the Board prior to the end of the annual meeting for the purpose of re-organizing the Board. Public announcement of election results will be made at the discretion of the president.
(h)(4) The terms of new commissioners will begin when they are seated at the reorganization meeting of the Board.
(h)(5) If an insufficient number of nominating petitions are filed to require balloting in a division, the person or persons nominated must be declared elected.
(h)(6) If any day or date set forth above falls on Saturday, Sunday or holiday, the act required or time fixed will occur on or run from the next working day.
(i) Disputed election.
(i)(1) If there is a dispute as to the validity of the election of a commissioner, it must be resolved by the Board at its first meeting after the election or at an adjourned meeting. Any Board member involved in the dispute must not be entitled to vote. The executive director must give written notice to each candidate of the hearing on the contested election and each candidate must have the right to be personally present, to be represented by counsel and to present proof at the hearing. The Board has the right to inquire into all matters germane to the election and dispute.
(i)(2) The Board may designate a committee from among its members to hear disputed election matters, but decisions of the committee will not be effective until approved by the Board. In every contested election hearing, the Board has the right to prescribe rules and regulations for the conduct.
(i)(3) The decision of the Board is final.
(j) Meetings.
(j)(1) The Board must hold regular meetings at the Bar offices or at such other place as the Board may determine.
(j)(2) Special meetings of the Board may be held at any time upon the call of the president, and must be called by him or her at the written request of three or more members of the Board.
(j)(3) Reasonable notice of the time and place of all regular special meetings must be given to each member of the Board by the executive director by email.
(j)(4) At any regular or special meeting of the Board, any business may be transacted which is within the power of the Board, whether or not such business has been placed upon the agenda in advance; provided, however, that advance notice pursuant to subparagraph (j)(3) above must be given for removal of officers and lawyer commissioners.
(j)(5) If less than a quorum of the Board is present at a meeting, those present may adjourn the meeting to a later time, and if a quorum is present at the time to which the meeting was adjourned, the Board may proceed with the conduct of business without further call or notice.
(j)(6) If the president desires the vote of the Board without calling a meeting, a vote may be taken by telephone or e-mail provided that all members of the Board are be given an opportunity to vote.
(k) Quorum. Eight members of the Board constitute a quorum for conducting the business of the Board and a majority vote of those present and voting at any meeting is sufficient to take effective action to bind the Board; provided, however, that the nomination of candidates to run for the office of president-elect and the selection of a lawyer commissioner to fill a vacancy must be by majority vote of the entire Board. All members of the Board who are present must vote on all matters when a vote is taken unless they excuse themselves from voting or are excused from voting by a majority of the Board members present because of a conflict of interest.
(l) Executive Committee. An Executive Committee of not fewer than three members, two of whom shall be the president and the president-elect, with the remaining members of the Executive Committee being voting members of the Board, must be appointed by the president with the approval of the Board. The executive director must be an ex-officio member of the Executive Committee. The duties of the Executive Committee shall include:
(l)(1) the handling of emergency matters when the entire Board cannot be convened, or the requirements of paragraph (g) above cannot be met;
(l)(2) the review of the affairs of the Bar and the making of recommendations to the Board;
(l)(3) the handling of ministerial and routine business of the Bar which transpires between Board meetings; and
(l)(4) any other matters delegated to it by the Board.
All recommendations and ministerial matters must be reported to the Board as a part of the agenda for the next Board meeting following the action.
(m) Liaison assignments. In addition to performing duties required by law or which may be assigned to individual members of the Board, commissioners and officers may be assigned as contacts or liaison representatives to the various committees, sections and units of the Bar, and in that capacity will have the authority to call meetings of the committees, sections or units of the Bar and may report thereafter at the meetings of the Board. The members of the Board and officers should affiliate and participate with, and be informed upon the work of the American Bar Association and other organizations on subjects relating to those under consideration by the Board, committees, sections and units of the Bar to which the Board members are assigned.
(n) Sub-committees. The Board may appoint sub-committees to carry out its functions.
(o) Executive Director.
(o)(1) The Executive Director is selected by the Board.
(o)(2) The salary, duties and employment term of the Executive Director are contained in the Executive Director’s employment agreement with the Board.
(o)(3) The Executive Director must perform duties as secretary to the Board as provided by law and any other duties prescribed by the Board or delegated by the president, not inconsistent with law and these Bylaws. The Executive Director has the authority to hire and terminate staff.
(p) Ex-officio members. Ex-officio members of the Board may be designated by the Board from year to year, but any designation must not be effective for more than one year, and ex-officio members are not entitled to vote.